What is FIRPTA and who does it apply to?
FIRPTA (Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act) is the 1980 law that allows the U.S. to tax foreign persons when they dispose of real property located in the country.
"Disposing" is not only selling. For the IRS it also includes exchanges, liquidations, gifts and other ways of transferring the property.
What matters is not your nationality or your passport, but your tax status. FIRPTA applies to a "foreign person", meaning someone who is a nonresident for tax purposes at the time of the sale. If you are not sure about your status, it is worth confirming that first.
Source: IRS: FIRPTA withholding
How much is withheld, and who does it
The general rule is that the buyer withholds 15% of the amount realized on the sale, which in practice is usually the sale price. Withholding is based on the price, not on the gain.
The buyer is the withholding agent. If the buyer fails to withhold when required, the buyer may be liable to the IRS for the tax that was not withheld. That is why closings in Florida ask early on whether the seller is a foreign person.
The law provides exceptions when the buyer is an individual who acquires the property to live in it and has definite plans to do so:
- Price up to US$300,000: no withholding.
- Price over US$300,000 and up to US$1,000,000: 10% is withheld.
- Price over US$1,000,000, or if the buyer will not use it as a residence: the general 15% applies.
Because withholding is based on the price and not on the gain, it can be much higher than the tax you actually owe.
Source: IRS: exceptions from FIRPTA withholding
Source: U.S. Code: section 1445
Before closing: the withholding certificate (Form 8288-B)
If the withholding would be higher than the maximum tax you should owe, you can ask the IRS for a withholding certificate so that less is withheld, or in some cases nothing.
The application is filed on Form 8288-B and can be submitted by the seller, the buyer or an authorized agent. The IRS generally responds within about 90 days after receiving a complete application, including the parties' taxpayer identification numbers.
If the application is still pending on the closing date, withholding still takes place. The difference is that the money is not sent to the IRS until there is a response, and it is then adjusted based on what the IRS determines.
Planning happens before you sign the purchase contract, not on closing day.
Source: IRS: withholding certificates
After closing: Forms 8288 and 8288-A, and how to recover what was withheld
- The buyer sends the amount withheld to the IRS with Forms 8288 and 8288-A, generally within 20 days after the sale.
- The IRS sends the seller a stamped Copy B of Form 8288-A. That document proves the withholding was paid on your behalf.
- Withholding does not close the matter. To receive credit for it, or to recover any excess, you must file your U.S. tax return (Form 1040-NR, if you are an individual) and attach that copy.
- If you do not file a return, the money withheld stays with the IRS, even if your actual tax was lower.
- For all of this you need a taxpayer identification number. If you do not have an ITIN or yours has expired, it needs to be resolved in time.
Source: IRS: reporting and paying tax on U.S. real property interests
Did you sell your main home? A point worth reviewing
The exclusion of gain on the sale of a main home (section 121 of the Code) can also apply to a nonresident. On Form 1040-NR, the maximum that can be excluded is US$250,000, provided the requirements are met.
Whether it applies depends on how long it was your home and other details of your case. It is not automatic: it is a point worth analyzing before you file.
Source: IRS: FIRPTA withholding
What is worth reviewing with a CPA
These situations have no one-size-fits-all answer and are worth reviewing with an expert:
- You are going to sell your U.S. property and do not know how much will be withheld.
- You believe the withholding will be higher than your actual tax.
- You already sold, tax was withheld, and you have not filed a return.
- You do not have an ITIN or yours has expired.
- The property is held through an LLC or a corporation: in that case the rules may be different.
Frequently asked questions
Is the 15% withholding the tax I have to pay?
No. It is an advance the buyer withholds from the price. Your actual tax is calculated on the gain in your return, and the amount withheld is credited against that tax.
Can I avoid or reduce the withholding?
In some cases, yes. There may be no withholding, or 10% instead of 15%, if the buyer is an individual who will use the property as a residence. You can also ask the IRS for a withholding certificate on Form 8288-B before closing.
How do I recover the money withheld?
By filing your U.S. tax return (Form 1040-NR, if you are an individual) with the stamped Copy B of Form 8288-A. If the withholding was higher than your tax, the IRS refunds the difference.
What happens if the buyer does not withhold?
The buyer may be liable to the IRS for the tax that was not withheld. You, as the seller, are still required to report the sale and pay the tax you owe.
