Are you a "nonresident" for the IRS?
For the IRS, tax residency does not depend on your visa or your citizenship. A foreign individual is a tax resident if they hold a green card or meet the substantial presence test, which is based on the days physically spent in the U.S. If you meet neither, you are a nonresident alien.
The difference matters: a resident is taxed on worldwide income, while a nonresident is generally taxed only on U.S.-source income.
It is also possible to be a resident for part of the year and a nonresident for the rest. This is called dual status, and it is common in the year someone arrives in or leaves the U.S.
The two types of income: ECI and FDAP
For a nonresident, the IRS splits U.S.-source income into two main groups, and that classification determines how much you pay:
- ECI (income effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business): taxed at the same graduated rates as a resident, with the related deductions allowed.
- FDAP (fixed or periodic income, such as dividends, interest, royalties or certain rents): taxed at a flat 30% on the gross amount, with no deductions, unless a tax treaty provides a lower rate.
The same amount of money can be taxed very differently depending on whether it is classified as ECI or FDAP. That is why it is worth understanding this before any other decision.
The most common case: renting out property in Florida
Many foreigners buy an apartment or a house in Florida and rent it out. That rent is U.S.-source income, because the source is where the property is located.
By default, the IRS treats it as FDAP: 30% is withheld on the gross rent, without subtracting expenses such as management, repairs, insurance, property tax or depreciation.
The law allows an alternative: electing to treat the rent as income effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business (ECI). With that election, tax is calculated on net rent, after expenses, at graduated rates.
Before making that decision, keep the following in mind:
- The election covers all of your U.S. rental properties, not just one.
- Once made, it stays in effect for the following years.
- It requires filing Form 1040-NR every year.
- The tenant or property manager receives Form W-8ECI instead of Form W-8BEN.
Paying tax on gross versus net rent can make a very large difference every year. It is a decision worth reviewing with a CPA before you make it, not after.
Who must file Form 1040-NR, and when?
Form 1040-NR is the nonresident's annual return. According to the IRS, you generally must file it if:
- You were engaged in a trade or business in the U.S. during the year.
- You had U.S.-source income whose tax was not fully covered by withholding.
- You want to claim a refund of excess withholding, or claim deductions, such as those for a rental with the ECI election.
Deadlines
- April 15, if you received wages subject to U.S. withholding or have an office or place of business in the U.S.
- June 15, in all other cases.
ITIN and W-8 forms: the nonresident's tax identity
- ITIN: the identification number the IRS issues to people who cannot get a Social Security number but need to file a return or claim treaty benefits. You apply with Form W-7.
- An ITIN expires if it is not used on a federal tax return for 3 consecutive years. If yours has expired, it must be renewed before you file.
- W-8BEN: certifies to the payer (bank, broker or fund) that you are a foreign person and lets you claim a reduced treaty rate. If you do not provide it, the payer may apply 30% withholding.
- W-8ECI: used for income treated as ECI, such as rent under the election described above.
Source: IRS: ITIN and Form W-7
Source: IRS: About Form W-8BEN
Is your property or business held through an LLC? You may also have a Form 5472 obligation.
Read our guide on foreign-owned LLCs and Form 5472Your case needs a professional review if...
These situations have no one-size-fits-all answer and are worth reviewing with an expert:
- You have a rental property in the U.S. and have never filed a return.
- 30% is being withheld and you do not know whether a tax treaty reduces it.
- You are not sure whether you are a resident, a nonresident or dual-status this year.
- You need an ITIN or yours has expired.
- You plan to sell your U.S. property (read our guide on FIRPTA).
Frequently asked questions
If I don't live in the U.S., do I have to file?
It depends on your income. If you had U.S.-source income whose tax was not covered by withholding, or you had a U.S. trade or business, you generally must file Form 1040-NR.
Can I deduct my rental expenses?
Only if you elect to treat the rent as income effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business and you file your return. Without that election, 30% withholding applies to the gross rent.
What happens if I didn't provide Form W-8BEN?
The payer may apply 30% withholding even if a treaty allows you a lower rate. It is worth reviewing your case to see whether it can be corrected or the excess recovered.
How long does my ITIN last?
An ITIN expires if it is not used on a federal tax return for 3 consecutive years. If it has expired, it must be renewed before you file your next return.
